THE COLUMN

by
 Nefreteri

The Identity Trap: Why Trying to Invent Yourself Fails

Hi! I'm

Nefreteri

I'm a logical girl living in an illogical world! I'm here slinging challenging life advice with a side of cool.  Life wasn't meant to be miserable. I want to show you. . .

TOP LINKS

instagram

tiktok

Youtube

Here's a Great Freebie or Something

And here's Information about it. Click here!

Discovering Your Identity the Right Way

(Note: The accompanying video essay explores these themes in a very conversational manner; the core arguments unfold below for additional reading and resources.)

October 11, 2024 | Episode 2

Description:
One of the biggest problems of today is our ever-changing identities.  Everyone is trying to figure out who they are.  It’s a fair question, because it makes sense that who you are will determine your choices and, thus, the future you’ll have.

But here’s the truth: one’s identity shouldn’t be ever-shifting. It comes from something far greater—your Creator. I’ll share the reasons why when your identity is anchored in an unchanging Person, you can walk confidently through life, knowing who you are. 🤍

If we take an honest look around us, many people today are struggling to figure out who they are. Young adults spend years feeling totally lost, bouncing back and forth between feeling like they aren’t good enough and acting like they know everything.

The world tells us a comforting lie: that you can invent your own identity and change who you are whenever you feel like it. But this endless search leaves people tired, confused, and stressed out. Let’s break down why this happens and what the real fix is.

“Your identity is the most powerful force in your life.  It determines your habits, influences your decisions, and predicts your future. Who you are determines how you act and behave.  Everything stems from your identity.”- James Clear

1. The Label Trap: Letting Jobs and Titles Define You

When you ask someone who they are, it’s amazing how many people will respond with their job title.  Some will say they’re a mom.  Some people feel overshadowed by famous or powerful parents and will introduce themselves as their child.  

Our obsession with labels and fitting in has us identifying by our race, sexuality, and gender.  Some of these labels are unchangeable, while others are constant, but ALL are superficial.  They don’t actually get to the depth of who we are.  We have reduced ourselves to superficial identifiers to fit in.

Today, society teaches us to build our entire identity around temporary things, such as:

  • Your Job: What you do for a living.
  • Your Roles: Being a boss, a parent, a spouse, or a child.
  • Micro-Labels: Defining your whole life by your favorite food, a subculture, or temporary trends.

When you tie your entire worth to a job or a temporary label, what happens when you lose that job or your kids grow up and move away? You feel like your whole life has collapsed. These are just things you do, not who you are.

2. The Trap of Fake Confidence and Self-Doubt

Without a solid anchor, people swing between two major extremes:

ProblemWhat It Looks LikeHow It Feels
Imposter SyndromeBelieving you are never smart enough or good enough, no matter what you achieve.Constant worry, stress, and feeling like a fake.
False ConfidencePretending you are great at everything without actually putting in any real work or skill.Arrogance, stubbornness, and a lack of self-awareness.

Both problems come from the same mistake: trying to figure out your worth based entirely on your own feelings or what other people say about you.

One of the biggest problems is the fluffy self-help advice being pandered to the public.

We have people who are fighting low self-esteem with positive affirmations, with no regard for truth.  These affirmations and positive self-talk have been so heavily ingrained into our society now that it has produced a group of overconfident and entitled people.

We’re fighting imposter syndrome on one side and narcissism on the other, all because we want people to have good vibes only. Truth becomes unnecessary.

3. Were You Made, or Did You Just Happen?

Our culture pushes the idea that humans are just the result of random chance and evolution—that we are basically smart animals with no real purpose. Evolution has stripped us of human dignity, making our lives purposeless and of no more value than apes. Friedrich Nietzsche, philosopher and critic, warned of the dangers in Darwinian evolution, but his desire to get rid of God as the originator of the Earth was more important.

Without a God, it’s hard to think individual lives have purpose if human life doesn’t have a purpose.

When people believe they have no real purpose, life feels empty. We try to fill that emptiness with self-help books and hobbies, but the deep need for meaning remains.

However, what if life isn’t an accident? What if you were made on purpose by a Creator who actually loves you? If you were created with a purpose, then your identity isn’t something you have to make up—it is something you were given.

“So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.” — Genesis 1:27

4. Why Self-Help Books Aren’t Enough

The modern self-help world tells you to fix your flaws using positive thinking, meditation, and willpower. While working hard is good, trying to completely change your inner nature all by yourself is exhausting.

Real, lasting change doesn’t come from a checklist or a mantra. It comes from a fresh start on the inside through Christ.

“Do not lie to one another, seeing that you have put off the old self with its practices and have put on the new self…” — Colossians 3:9–10

Identity and mindset shifts are hard work and circumstantial.  Self-help books are made for the masses.  They don’t meet you where you are.  You could be in a hard place and not have the ability to help yourself. The self-help industry doesn’t care if you fall through the cracks.

Jesus Christ, on the other hand, offers to do the hard work for you by saying, “Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.” (Matt 11:28). He offers permanent and complete change.

Some of the character changes Jesus will help you achieve:

  • A compassionate heart
  • Kindness
  • Humility
  • Patience
  • Putting up with other people
  • Forgiving people who have wronged you
  • REAL LOVE ❤️🤍- it brings everything else together

Key Takeaways

  • Identity is Given, Not Made: Your true worth comes from being made by God, not from your job or social media labels.
  • Roles Change, You Stay: Jobs and titles come and go, but a solid identity stays steady through life’s changes.
  • Ditch the Extremes: True confidence doesn’t come from bragging or from doubting yourself—it comes from knowing who you were made to be.
  • Real Change Comes From God: Lasting character growth comes from a new start on the inside, not just from trying harder on your own.

Standing on Truth

True truth doesn’t change just to fit in with the latest trends. Your identity is an objective fact rooted in your Creator, not in what the world tells you to be today. Try to imagine life from the eyes of a Benevolent Creator. If you can believe there is a God who loves you, you can believe you were created for a purpose. When you know who you were made to be, you don’t have to keep searching.

Resources

Scripture Verses

Genesis 1:27 | Jeremiah 1:5 | Ephesians 2:10 | 2 Corinthians 5:17 | Colossians 3:9-10, 12-15

Hi, I'm Nef

Edgy, rebellious, sporty, bookworm. I'll try almost anything at least once. I never sacrifice fun for hard work. I love them BOTH.

READ          LATEST

the

Other places

Making wisdom fashionable

Follow Me @_nefreteri